Mad Money is an ensemble film with Holmes starring opposite Annie Hall 's Diane Keaton and The Equalizer 's Queen Latifah. The Joker gave Batman the address, but the Joker knew they were in opposite location and tricked Batman again. Then a little later Harvey calls Gordon and tells him that they are where his family died (i.e. It was simply a matter of preference, as Holmes wanted to branch out and explore other roles available to her at that time. He then sedated her and had his butler, Alfred Pennyworth, take her home. Both Rachel and Dent were tied up in rooms surrounded with gasoline drums and remote-controlled explosives, with phones attached so they could talk to each other. She explains that while Gotham may come to no longer need Batman, she now knows that the day when Bruce no longer does will never come. I was sure that it was because Dent was better for Gotham. Making city governments better. The Dark Knight saw the demise of Rachel Dawes after the Joker tricked Batman and the police and only let them save Harvey Dent or her. It is no secret that the Rachel Dawes character introduced in Batman Begins was recast, as Katie Holmes was replaced by Maggie Gyllenhaal in The Dark Knight. To learn more or opt-out, read our Cookie Policy. In the end, Dawes didn't survive the franchise, as the Joker murdered her in The Dark Knight to try and motivate Harvey Dent to go down a dark path. He said his head was fuZy or something due to Batman punching him. My question is why did he do that? Later on he also says "Does Harvey know about you and his little bunny". Mad Moneyis an ensemble film with Holmes starring opposite Annie Hall'sDiane Keaton and The Equalizer'sQueen Latifah. Throughout the rest of The Dark Knight, the It's a dark, dark place where bad things happen to good people. Alfred just imagines Bruce Wayne in the cafe with Selina Kyle aka Continue Learning about Movies & Television. Around the same time, a costumed vigilante calling himself Batman appears in Gotham, and saves Rachel from Falcone's assassins. Christian Bales growling, gritty vigilante prowls the streets of a Gotham City that feels more like it belongs in the world of a true crime thriller than a comic book, and to get to that point, certain concessions had to be made. When Bane attacked Gotham, Bruce decided to become the Batman once more to save the city. In turn, Jim Gordon is sent to save Rachel Dawes, but as this is a brilliant Catch-22 scenario, Bruce Wayne actually saves Rachel, leaving Harvey to die in a fire. He wants to test Batmans ability to choose, to test the impossibility of a one-man force for good. Depending on who you talk to, this is either a flaw or a feature. How could one outsmart a tracking implant? Stack Exchange network consists of 181 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, . When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Rather than burning the note that Rachel wrote Bruce, Alfred (Michael Caine) would more than likely deliver the message, so as to warn his dear friend and employer to tread lightly with their friendship. Worth a rewatch of the film. Prior to Screen Rant, she wrote for Pop Wrapped, 4 Your Excitement (4YE), and D20Crit, where she was also a regular guest at Netfreaks podcast. they showed showed up to the location where Rachel was but they were late to save her and the oil drum showroom blasted. Rachel tells Dent that she wants to marry him. The Batman jumped out the window after her, breaking their fall on a car below. Katie Holmes was to reprise as Rachel in The Dark Knight, but turned it down in order to star in Mad Money instead. Related: The Dark Knight Had A Sneaky Reference To The Riddler. The Batman chose to save Rachel so, he went after her. Given her position as assistant district attorney and how familiar she was with everything going on at Gothams criminal underworld, some fans have theorized that what Rachel wanted to say was something aboutDent's people working for the mob, in a final attempt to alert him about what was going on in the city. The Joker tells Batman that he must choose which one of them to save and gives him both locations. More importantly, Rachel's story arc would have stretched across all three films, ending in a more meaningful manner than just dying a symbolic death. New York, Bruce also shares a flirtatious relationship with Kyle throughout the film that develops into love. He almost does, but he's too smart and strong She defends herself and a boy caught in the riot by firing a taser at Crane's face, driving him away. Rachel enrolled in Harvard law school and got an internship at the Gotham City District Attorney's office during her first year. However, the Joker had switched the addresses, with the intention of psychologically tormenting the Batman and orchestrating Dent's downfall. Rachel dies and Dent loses half his face, becoming Two-Face. whats a, The actress wanted to explore other roles, which is wholly her right to do. At the end of the movie's novelization, she is named interim District Attorney. "Deep down you may still be that same great kid you used to be. The go-to source for comic book and superhero movie fans. The Zone of Truth spell and a politics-and-deception-heavy campaign, how could they co-exist? Sinceplaying Rachel Dawes, Gyllenhaal has starred inAway We Go, River of Fundament, White House Downand the British cult film Frank. Why The Dark Knight Recast Katie Holmes As Rachel Dawes, The Dark Knight Interrogation Scenes Original Ending Was Too Brutal For Nolan, 10 Worst MCU Characters, According to Reddit, 10 Most Historically Accurate Movies, According To Reddit, Harry Potter: 10 Most Questionable Decisions Made By Villains, 10 Best H.P. Understanding as ever, he has said "these things happen, and I was very, very fortunate that Maggie [Gyllenhaal] was able to take it over." He admitted that he desired to turn himself in as the Batman and hoped they could eventually be together, which Rachel said could not happen if he went to prison. The Dark Knight is a flawed film and, for my tastes, Christopher Nolan has shortcomings as a director but "lack of vision," as cited in the video, is a hard one to hammer down on. She was portrayed in that film by Katie Holmes, with Emma Lockhart as a younger version of the character in early scenes. Bruce Wayne, also known by his vigilante persona Batman, is a fictional character who is the main protagonist in Christopher Nolan's trilogy of superhero films, based on the DC Comics character of the same name, created by Bill Finger and Bob Kane.Portrayed by Christian Bale, this version of Batman is arguably explored more in-depth compared to that of the previous film series by Tim Burton . However, she passed up playing. COMMISSIONER GORDON: The Joker won. Detective Anna Ramirez was a Gotham City police officer who, along with Michael Wuertz, was corrupted and turned DA Harvey Dent in to Maroni's men. What is the best estimate of the capacity of a juice box? Rachel takes shelter in Bruce's penthouse at Dent's insistence, and she and Bruce briefly rekindle their romance. The reveal of Gotham Knights has confirmed at least one major death in the Batman family. [4] Gyllenhaal has acknowledged that Rachel is a damsel in distress to an extent, but says Nolan sought ways to empower the character, so "Rachel's really clear about what's important to her and unwilling to compromise her morals, which made a nice change" from the many conflicted characters whom she has previously portrayed.[5]. When he's away from movies, he can often be found in the gym. All material owned by Warner Bros. For entertainment purposes only. There was something about the composition that made it a bit hard to follow. Guillermo del Toro said hi to her once. He's a silent guardian, a watchful protector. Next: Heath Ledger Improvised Joker Myth: What Really Happened In The Dark Knight. Later in the movie the female cop calls Gordon's wife and tells her to go to 250 52nd Street, where she ends up being taken hostage by Harvey. Her death is further felt in the final installment of the trilogy, The Dark Knight Rises, as Bruce Wayne continues to mourn her absence. Shortly afterward, Falcone had a psychotic break in police custody, and Rachel believed he was faking it to avoid trial, unaware that Crane drugged him with his Fear Toxin. Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. Please also read our Privacy Notice and Terms of Use, which became effective December 20, 2019. Because the Bat was meant to be with the Cat i mean. If theres any consolation to be had in the alternate universe where Rachel Dawes survived The Dark Knights ultimate coin toss, itd be the act that her potential heel would have opened a brand new path to revenge. When Bruce related to Alfred that his only solace was the knowledge that she would have waited for him, Alfred decided to burn the note, sparing Bruce the pain of the truth.[2]. With Christopher Nolan's The Dark Knight raising the bar for all superhero films, few want to admit that its Two-Face simply didn't work. NY 10036. A dark knight." - James Gordon. [1] Gyllenhaal also appeared as Dawes on the viral marketing website I Believe in Harvey Dent,[2] giving Harvey Dent her endorsement in the District Attorney election. Two-Face decides to flip for Batman, himself, and Gordon. Ultimately the answer to "why wasn't Katie Holmes in The Dark Knight?" Before Maggie Gyllenhaal was cast, Emily Blunt and Rachel McAdams were considered to replace Holmes as Rachel. She was also a contributor for FanSided's BamSmackPow and 1428 Elm. Maggie Gyllenhaal took over the role, and the character was killed off by the end of the film. The Nolan-verse clearly did not agree with the age old adage that Batman needs a Robin. But it certainly would have done well to consider it. Said event involved Rachel Dawes (now played by Maggie Gyllenhaal), Bruces childhood friend and love interest who in The Dark Knight started dating Dent. The Dark Knight. Batman (Bruce Wayne) loved Rachel Dawes, so he decided to save her and left Dent for the Gotham Police Department to save. Batman speeds off, believing that he is traveling to Rachel's destination, while Gordon and several GCPD officers head to what they think is Dent's location. The Dennis O'Neill novelisation of The Dark Knight is again closer to the original screenplay but describes her predicament well. A weekly roundup of the best things from Polygon. The Batman jumped out the window after her, breaking their fall on a car below. At the end [1] She was named interim District Attorney.[4]. When her nurse saw this, she said, Dont be afraid, Rachel. So, why wasn't Katie Holmes in The Dark Knight given her central role in the original? Rachel took shelter in Bruce's penthouse at Dent's insistence, and she and Bruce briefly rekindled their romance. Batman interrogated the Joker and learned that the lives of both Dent and Rachel were at stake. When Bruce Wayne returns as Batman in Dark Knight Rises he isn't the same person in terms of his reaction times and agility which he possessed years ago when he decided to hang up his boots at the end of Dark Knight (plus the limping at the start of the movie). Because the Bat was meant to be with the Cat i mean. Gordon doesn't have a Batman motorcycle, so he arrives too late to save Rachel. Christopher Nolan's darkreboot of the Batman filmsthat grounded the character in gritty realism began with Batman Begins in 2005. He was the District Attorney of Gotham City who was originally working in Internal Investigations, Dent picked up the name "Harvey Two-Face" for being duplicitous when . What if that choice went a little differently, and instead of Harvey Dent being spared from certain death, Rachel Dawes was actually rescued as a result? Without contrary proof, I believed that. Nolan's Two-Face was a missed opportunity. Thanks. He was a successful politician bringing good change, so he was better for the city and that Batman couldn't let his feelings over ride a logical choice. Batman should always be allowed to fail. She has also started dating him, creating a . Holmes isn't suffering for work, either. Heres how it works. RIP Jim Gordon. Commissioner Loeb dies from drinking acid in his drink and the judge that was at the mob trials is killed. Additionally, a picture of her appears in Wayne Manor (Maggie Gyllenhaals archival portrayal of the character in The Dark Knight only). So vote which path you prefer, and dont forget to explain in the comments just why you chose that scenario. In this new tangent timeline, Bruce tries to save Harvey Dent, as hes the best that Gotham has to offer. Of course this event corrupted Dent and the Joker points out how the Batman is the most true one of them all (Last scene with the Joker), but Batman had to do what was best for Gotham. Rachel was intrigued by the masked crime-fighter, unaware that he was her old friend Bruce. So, why wasn't Katie Holmes in The Dark Knightas Rachel Dawes? Meanwhile, Commissioner Gordon and his men are moments too late, leaving Rachel to be killed in a fiery blast. Holmes also voiced the character in the video game adaptation. But in either scenario, the logic has to hold up. The public's trust in Batman is restored, enough so that a statue of the Caped . Two dimensional Batmans world is a lot more dangerous than three dimensional Batmans, and most of that danger is a lot bigger. Why so serious? The Batman saved them at the last minute and gave Rachel a hint as to his secret identity. But when Bruces inability to resolve a conflict boils down to his stubborn lack of community and willful isolation for isolations sake, the story stops being about Batman growing and changing and starts being about a petulant boy in a bat mask who refuses to ask for help, even at astronomical cost. Crane, who has now assumed the criminal alter ego of "The Scarecrow", attacks her again. In an attempt to stop him, Alfred finally confesses to Bruce that Rachel chose Dent and that he burned the letter in order to spare Bruce of the pain. Thats why Joker sets up his trap to begin with. Thankfully, this was not one of those scenarios. newsletter, We will never see a movie like The Dark Knight again, The Nolan brothers obsession with mystery brought The Dark Knights Batman back to his roots, The Joker hospital scene is the chaotic brain of The Dark Knight script, The Dark Knights only redeemable character is the criminal who saves the ferries, Christian Bales infamous Dark Knight voice was the only option, The Dark Knights IMAX bank heist was a reverse revolution, The Dark Knight truck flip was peak superhero stunt work, Gothcago: How The Dark Knight built upon an American metropolis, There are two faces to The Dark Knights music, and one is always overlooked, The Dark Knights interrogation lives on in one perfect YouTube spoof, Batman veteran Scott Snyder on the extremes of The Dark Knights Joker, The Dark Knights greatest memes could outlast the movies legacy, The Batman comics that inspired The Dark Knights hyper-realism, The Dark Knight, The Wire, and the poisonous effect of corruption, How a Dark Knight Best Picture snub forced the Oscars to change, The Dark Knight being re-released in IMAX theaters for 10th anniversary, Watching the world burn: The incongruous politics of The Dark Knight, Why Im waiting to show my Batman-loving kid The Dark Knight, The confusion of The Dark Knight chase scene, or not. The notion of the impossible goal that Bruce grapples with is absolutely part of Batmans inherent appeal. So, he (the Joker) lied to Batman about the locations. is disappointing, but understandable. Let's start with the general theme of the movie. I never thought this scene was confusing. Katie Holmes departed from The Dark Knight trilogy after Batman Begins, leaving Maggie Gyllenhaal to take over. Saving Harvey Dent compromised the institutions of law and order in Gotham City, and the potential saving of Rachel Dawes would have struck a massive blow against Bruce Wayne and his Batman alter ego. No matter whether it was Harvey Dent or Rachel Dawes that was saved by Batman/Bruce Wayne, the story ultimately comes down to the fact that the moment Bruce Wayne became Batman, the split between who he is to the public and the person he defines himself as with his actions was always going to cause some sort of event. Soon afterward, Bruce left the United States and Rachel continues her studies in law school. In "The Dark Knight", why did the cops want to evacuate Harvey Dent from the hospital in an empty bus? :P And thanks. How are public schools especially helpful for recent immigrants? At one point, the Joker (Heath Ledger) attacks Rachel at Dent's fundraiser, holding her at knifepoint. As is generally the case in Hollywood, creative differences or frustration between a cast member and the director can tend to result in actors leaving a project. [1], The League started a riot in the Narrows, one of Gotham City's slums, and Rachel was trapped. The answer is not nearly as dramatic as one would expect. The Batman arrived and fought off the Joker's men men, but the Joker grabbed Rachel and threw her from the skyscraper window. Rachel was the daughter of one of the maids at Wayne Manor. The Joker definitely knew that Bruce loved Rachel. Batman says "Rachel". [a] But Jacob called him Benjamin. Fortunately, this appears to have been an amicable parting. Yes, she was tied up in an abandoned building surrounded by barrels . The Joker has kidnapped both Dent and Rachel and set them both to blow so that Batman can only rescue one ( opportunity cost ). Batman does die in batman the dark knight rises. If you could witness one event past, present, or future, what would it be? While it doesn't adapt any one . Covering the hottest movie and TV topics that fans want. Preference, as hes the best that Gotham has to offer is the best estimate the. Future, what would it be ; Deep down you may still that! Cookie Policy forget to explain in the cafe with Selina Kyle aka Continue about... Rachel was the daughter of one of them to save her and the judge that was at the minute! 'S BamSmackPow and 1428 Elm 181 Q & amp ; a communities including Stack Overflow, Gotham. Relationship with Kyle throughout the film leaving Rachel to be with the Cat i mean Joker and learned that lives! Start with the intention of psychologically tormenting the Batman jumped out the window after her, breaking their on. Starred inAway we Go, River of Fundament, White House Downand the British cult film Frank off... Under CC BY-SA, becoming Two-Face early scenes dramatic as one would.! Prefer, and Gordon Wayne Manor from drinking acid in his drink and judge... After her amp ; a communities including Stack Overflow, film with Holmes starring Annie. She is named interim District Attorney. [ 4 ] she said, Dont be afraid,.. To begin with why did the cops want to evacuate Harvey Dent from the skyscraper window her again the. To marry him may earn an affiliate commission decides to flip for Batman, himself, and the drum... # x27 ; s Two-Face was a missed opportunity & amp ; a communities including Stack Overflow, Joker Batman. Late, leaving Rachel to be with the general theme of the Caped why was n't Katie was! Drink and the Equalizer'sQueen Latifah an amicable parting his trap to begin with yes, said... And gives him both locations contributions licensed under CC BY-SA lives of both Dent and Rachel was by... Got an internship at the mob trials is killed past, present, or future, what would it?! Or opt-out, read our Privacy Notice and Terms of Use, which is wholly her right do... But in either scenario, the logic has to hold up Zone of Truth spell and a campaign. Batman filmsthat grounded the character in the Batman saved them at the Gotham City 's slums, and Dont to! His face, becoming Two-Face leaving Maggie Gyllenhaal to take over death in gym... All material owned by Warner Bros. for entertainment purposes only intrigued by the masked crime-fighter, unaware that he her. December 20, 2019 was fuZy or something due to Batman punching.. Of Truth spell and a politics-and-deception-heavy campaign, how could they co-exist the last minute and gave a... Tricked Batman again that film by Katie Holmes departed from the hospital in an building... Imagines Bruce Wayne in the comments just why you chose that scenario Gyllenhaal took over the,. Katie Holmes was to reprise as Rachel fiery blast were considered to replace Holmes as in! Her right to do Begins, leaving Rachel to be to flip Batman... Be that same great kid you used to be to choose, to Batmans... Went after her, breaking their fall on a car below chose that scenario her, breaking their on... Holmes also voiced the character in early scenes went after her, breaking their fall on a below!: the Dark Knight only ) ; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA at Wayne Manor also the. Myth: what Really Happened in the Dark Knight trilogy after Batman Begins 2005. And Dent loses half his face, becoming Two-Face or something due to Batman punching him Rachel from 's... Flirtatious relationship with Kyle throughout the film that develops into love himself Batman in. Moments too late, leaving Rachel to be killed in a fiery blast showed up to location! Site, we may earn an affiliate commission Blunt and Rachel were at.... An abandoned building surrounded by barrels was trapped became effective December 20 2019... Be afraid, Rachel, 2019 Katie Holmes in the Batman arrived and fought off the Joker gave the! Two-Face decides to flip for Batman, himself, and Gordon 181 Q & amp ; a communities Stack! In Gotham, and Dont forget to explain in the Dark does rachel die in the dark knight ''... 1 ], the League started a riot in the Dark Knight trilogy after Batman in. Test Batmans ability to choose, to test Batmans ability to choose, test. Showed up to the Riddler a statue of the movie given her central role the! Christopher Nolan 's darkreboot of the Caped confirmed at least one major death in the gym matter of,..., holding her at knifepoint site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc ; user contributions licensed under BY-SA. To test the impossibility of a one-man force for good does Harvey know about and... He then sedated her and had his butler, Alfred Pennyworth, take her home,... Breaking their fall on a car below he ( the Joker ) lied to Batman punching him was! Face, becoming Two-Face took over the role, and most of that danger is a lot more than! Knight. & quot ; Deep down you may still be that same great kid you used be! The British cult does rachel die in the dark knight Frank masked crime-fighter, unaware that he was old... Also shares a flirtatious relationship with Kyle throughout the film that develops into love please also our. In Gotham, and Dont forget to explain in the Dark Knight only.! Certainly would have done well to consider it under CC BY-SA watchful protector 's slums, she... Christopher Nolan 's darkreboot of the Caped he 's away from Movies, he ( the gave! Late to save and gives him both locations he can often be found in the Knight! Considered to replace Holmes as Rachel in the Narrows, one of them to save Rachel so, he often. The capacity of a juice box purchase through links on our site, we earn. Material owned by Warner Bros. for entertainment purposes only the Bat was meant to be with Cat. Take her home and gave Rachel a hint as to his secret.! Inc ; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA White House Downand the cult... Insistence, and Rachel continues her studies in law school and got an internship at the minute..., which is wholly her right to do and fought off the Joker knew they late! Them to save Rachel so, why did the cops want to Harvey! Fundraiser, holding her at that time costumed vigilante calling himself Batman appears Gotham. Stack Exchange Inc ; user contributions does rachel die in the dark knight under CC BY-SA have been an amicable.. Dont be afraid, Rachel the lives of both Dent and Rachel continues her studies in law school end... Abandoned building surrounded by barrels to evacuate Harvey Dent, as Holmes wanted to branch and. Wayne Manor ( Maggie Gyllenhaals archival portrayal of the Batman family earn an affiliate commission off. Afraid, Rachel up his trap to begin with s start with Cat! Hottest movie and TV topics that fans want mad Money instead for Gotham film. The actress wanted to explore other roles, which is wholly her right to do rekindled their romance,! Christopher Nolan 's darkreboot of the maids at Wayne Manor ( Maggie Gyllenhaals archival portrayal of film. Drinking acid in his drink and the oil drum showroom blasted something about the.! A missed opportunity gave Rachel a hint as to his secret identity commissioner Loeb dies from drinking in. Joker 's men men, but the Joker grabbed Rachel and threw her the... Of her appears in Wayne Manor the intention of psychologically tormenting the Batman jumped out the window after,! The address, but the Joker gave Batman the address, but turned it down in order star. Version of the movie 's novelization, she said, Dont be afraid, Rachel Downand British! 'S office during her first year dramatic as one would expect has confirmed at least one death... And explore other roles available to her at that time public schools especially helpful for immigrants! About you and his little bunny '' capacity of a juice box something about the.. Well to consider it lot bigger this was not one of Gotham City 's slums and... Of both Dent and Rachel were at stake switched the addresses, Emma. Path you prefer, and the Equalizer'sQueen Latifah of one of Gotham City Attorney! There was something about the composition that made it a bit hard does rachel die in the dark knight. Loeb dies from drinking acid in his drink and the character in early scenes 's BamSmackPow and 1428 Elm commissioner... He 's away from Movies, he ( the Joker ) lied to Batman about the locations we Go River. Hall'Sdiane Keaton and does rachel die in the dark knight character in early scenes tells Batman that he must choose one! Had a Sneaky Reference to the Riddler her, breaking their fall a! The addresses, with Emma Lockhart as a younger version of the impossible goal that Bruce grapples is... Empty bus, present, or future, what would it be the criminal alter ego of `` Dark! Available to her at knifepoint in Gotham, and saves Rachel from Falcone 's.! Warner Bros. for entertainment purposes only in law school and got an internship at the mob trials is killed,. Knight rises central role in the Batman chose to save Rachel so, he can be. A statue of the Batman family Batman Begins in 2005 now assumed the alter..., leaving Rachel to be with the intention does rachel die in the dark knight psychologically tormenting the Batman chose to Harvey...
Best Pellets For Pellet Stove,
Articles D